Always delicious no matter what I order. Staff great as well. Bartender is talented too!

4.5 stars. A group of 8 of us went to this restaurant on New Years Eve with an 8:30 seating. I have heard of this restaurant for awhile now and the buzz has been very positive. There is adjacent parking and valet parking which was appreciated as rain was anticipated. The restaurant is visually appealing, large and decorated beautifully for the holidays. With many large groups the volume of the crowd can be high. I had a direct sight line of the bar TV's for the Fiesta Bowl which was lucky for us. Our table was a bit small for 8 but on on NYE it is to be expected. The sharp crowd was generally 30's-50's and I was trying to get a read of where the crowd is from- neighboring Rye, Mamaroneck plus locals? There was music at a moderate volume early on. A basket of breads and a small cold app plate is served immediately which I think is great. Service was proficient from a team of well dressed servers. Management uses a large volume of staff to keep things moving along-bussers and runners- which is really smart! At 10pm the music is amped up and the crowd is itching to get up and move. The overall food quality is excellent. Apps of carpaccio, baked clams, artichokes, hot app plate and cold seafood were all very good. Some of the entree portions border on the skimpy side (veal Marsala) but overall not an issue. The Value equation for the experience was fine. Many of us had pasta dishes and there was a large list of non-priced specials available. We did not have desserts as we were headed to a house party for the ball drop. I look forward to returning to this restaurant with a smaller group and not on a holiday as to garner the regular night experience. We'll done on my first experience.

The ambiance, food, and service are all amazing! Our new favorite - highly recommen!

Went Christmas Day place was full for a 6:00 reservation. Had drinks at bar and were seated in 10 minutes. Ordered chicken, veal martini all very good. Ambience was good with many locals. Service was good not great.

Just went too Sergio's for the second time and I was very impressed. The service was out of this world. Me and 15 of my buddies had our holiday party and we couldn't have been happier. Whoever decorated for the holidays deserves a pat on the back it was absolutely beautiful. The waiters were very attentive and polite took our drink orders and had them ready within minutes. For dinner I had the pollo alla Diavola which was organic chicken served with a side of potatoes and Italian sausage that was phenomenal. I had a chance to try my buddies tomahawk steak which serves two people that was also very good I highly recommend. Another tip make sure you make a reservation because every they get very busy for dinner espically On a Friday night. One last thing make sure if you have dessert try the chocolate lava cake!!

Loved the ambiance of the "patio" and our starters were superb so we had high hopes for the entrees. Unfortunately they fell a bit short of that expectation - probably because of the huge engagement party going on so I don't think this was normal. The Marsala was bland and my fettuccine special also fell short - perfect shrimps but the crabmeat tasted canned and dish could be done without it - there was barely any sauce and flavor in this dish. The pasta was perfect though - obviously homemade. Service was lovely but also a little slow - again because of the party I'm sure. Will definitely be back though - really an enchanting spot.

A great place for an elegant night out. This place is Amore, because what's not to love. The atmosphere is beautiful. The service is great, and the food is pretty amazing. The Veal Martini is epic compared to the Veal Marsala, which was pretty good too. This place is great for private parties with TVs to watch the game at the bar. I forgot how good this place was. When it comes to finding the perfect spot worth breaking my no carb diet over, this is that place. Their chocolate lava cake looks amazing. This place is great. I will be back!!!

High end Italian restaurant with impeccable service. Enjoyed cheese and bread for each table, lamb chops were excellent. Dessert of apple strudel and ice cream reminded me of Vienna. Beautiful interior .

I was 100% surprised when we visited on a holiday weekend evening. The space felt at first a little stuffy, and we were very confused by who our waiter was and how long it would take to order, but all of a sudden, everything clicked, and we ended up having an awesome meal here. There's no by-the-glass wine list, but we were both pleased with our reds (Montepulciano for the win!). We loved the little plate of food and bread we got pretty immediately after sitting down. I can't remember the last place we've gotten such a nice starter. We loved our food. The farro salad was amazingly fulfilling and delicious; I would eat this type of dish everyday if I could. My partner's short rib and risotto were melty and delicious. It was a great special; get it next time you see it! I did find that the waitstaff continued to be a little impersonal during this dinner journey, but they definitely seem to have a system for taking care of all the customers across the whole restaurant. I'd definitely come back.